Short weight and quality claims: debit notes and credit notes
The buyer weighs the lorry and finds 72 kg short. The paddy came in wet. A rate was agreed lower after delivery. Each is settled with a note against the original bill or invoice — here is which note, and what it does to the books.
By the MillMargin team · Updated 19 Nov 2026 · 3 min read
The short answer
Never change an invoice or bill after it has gone out. Issue a note against it instead. A credit note lowers what a customer owes you; a debit note lowers what you owe a supplier. Each note names the original document, the reason and the amount.
Which note, and who issues it
| What happened | Note | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Your buyer claims short weight or poor quality | Credit note to the customer | Sales | Customer |
| You claim short weight or poor quality from a supplier | Debit note to the supplier | Supplier | Purchases or stock |
| Goods returned to you | Credit note to the customer | Sales returns | Customer |
| You return goods to a supplier | Debit note to the supplier | Supplier | Purchases or stock |
Worked example: a short-weight claim on a sale
SI-0018 sold Karim Grain Co. 640 bags of 1121 sella, 31,952 kg at Rs 143 per kg. Their weighbridge shows 31,880 kg: 72 kg short. You agree the claim.
| CN-0004 against SI-0018 | Debit | Credit | Rs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Short weight, 72 kg × 143.00 | Sales · rice | Karim Grain Co. | 10,296 |
The invoice still shows the full 4,569,136 for the rice; the note brings what Karim Grain Co. owes down by 10,296. Both documents stay in the books, so anyone can see the claim and why.
Worked example: a quality claim on paddy
PB-0031 bought 40,000 kg of paddy from Bhatti Paddy Co. The moisture was above the agreed level, and you settle on Rs 150 off per 40 kg.
| DN-0002 against PB-0031 | Debit | Credit | Rs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality claim, 40,000 kg ÷ 40 × 150 | Bhatti Paddy Co. | Paddy stock, lot 21 | 150,000 |
Invented businesses and figures.
Crediting the lot rather than a general income account keeps the lot's cost right: the paddy really cost Rs 150,000 less.
Settling the note
- Reduce the original document — the usual case when the bill or invoice is still unpaid.
- Keep it as an open credit — taken off the next payment or receipt with that party.
- Refund the money — when the original was already paid in full: a payment to the customer, or a receipt from the supplier.
If you are registered for sales tax
In Pakistan, under the Sales Tax Rules, a debit or credit note refers to the original tax invoice by number and date, and shows the value and the sales tax involved. FBR's rules for integrated businesses say that no return or exchange is entertained without that reference, and those businesses must issue the notes electronically. Your tax adviser will confirm which rules apply to you.
Questions traders ask
Can I just edit the invoice instead?
Better not. The party already has the original. A note keeps both documents, the reason and the date, and your statement still agrees with theirs.
The buyer says the bardana weight was wrong, not the rice.
It is still short weight on what you charged for. Work the claim on the kilos they did not get, at the invoice rate.
The claim is in dollars on an export invoice.
Issue the note in dollars at the original invoice's rate, so it cancels exactly the part of the invoice it relates to.
Should claims go to a separate account?
If you want to see how much claims cost you in a year, post credit notes to a Sales returns and allowances account instead of Sales. The profit is the same either way.
Every note is raised against its original invoice or bill, with the reason kept. Reduce that document, keep an open credit or refund the money — and print the note as a PDF.
Start your Ledger books free